My current budget and being a tightwad
Gee…this is long. Brevity is not the word of the day.
My new raise kicked in this month. I immediately increased my savings (from 5%) and my contribution to my defined contribution (401(k)) plan from 5% to 10% reducing my federal income tax by a few bucks every paycheck. I get 100% matching for the first 5%. Retirement also includes my IRA. Currently we’re not paying anything toward husband’s retirement (if I die and husband decided not to kill himself from grief, he’ll get life insurance proceeds). If I get my expected raise a year from now, I will start contributing toward his retirement account and possibly pay toward his student loan as well, since we’ll be flush with cash. This is the benefit of being extremely frugal. Any extra cash feels like we’ve won the lottery. This is how my income breaks out (numbers based on gross income)
| Retirement | 17.36% |
| Savings | 14.53% |
| Student Loan | 2.50% |
| Taxes + Medicare + etc taxed stuff | 18.86% |
| Living Expenses | 46.76% |
Savings includes my health savings account. I am supporting myself and husband on this salary. Husband’s PT job wages goes toward his student loan payments which is not included in here. If you’re wondering what my salary is: its $39,086 gross.
I notice many people find my blog searching for information on living a tightwad lifestyle. I suppose I better dole out some advice. So…listen up.
Neither of us feel deprived with our lifestyle or my income. There are days when I feel positively wealthy. Once in a while I feel a bit mopey over my small savings account and the fact that I spent a fortune eating crappy food for so many years…but I guess I had to go through that to arrive where I am today.
We follow all the usual personal finance advice: brown bagging lunches every day, making from scratch, turning down heat, etc, etc. Basically all the boring stuff that a magazine like Kiplingers comes up with every few months. And I am a nickle and dime type of person, so I strongly believe that all the small actions contribute toward substantial savings in the long run. But at the same time, I will spend alot of money on a product if I believe its worth it…such as a Wüsthof Chef’s knife or a good quality cast iron pan.
So what are the unusual things we do to save money or live a thrifty life?
1. We are childfree. While I made up my mind only very recently over this issue, I think the fact that I used birth control and had an abortion fund for years has been a very significant source of saving money and being aware of the cost of being a parent.
2. We are pet free. This decision has often been made for us as most rental units discourage pet owners from renting in a variety of ways. And my husband and I are just plain lazy. Having to feed another being would take away time from us lounging around being lazy. I don’t think this is going to be a lifelong decision however. I have realized that there are some very practical reasons where I would need the following: dog, cat, hawk, goat, hen. So maybe when we finally get our own land, we might get some critters.
3. We are car free. This too was a decision made for me…or rather, owning a car was never a priority for me. My husband got rid of his car in the late 90s when he discovered that we was paying more in car insurance for his junker than the car was worth. And since we love living in urban environments, a car is often a nuisance.
4. Our hobbies are free or cheap. So we don’t own a television (we watch DVDs on my computer) or play the latest computer games, anything that requires a steady payment (except for our naked dsl line). We love biking, reading, and talking. Additionally, I actively spend time limiting my exposure to advertisements whether on TV or online. I am weak in the head so I don’t see a need to expose my poor brain to wealthy marketing firms’ gimmicks.
5. We try out crazy experiments. And I use the word crazy only because other people say its crazy. These experiements don’t save money as much as expose us to a new way of thinking. One of my first experiments was done when I was single and 18. I decided to quit watching television for a month. At the time, I thought that the single worst thing that could happen to me would be missing my favorite television show. I found that sentiment to be disturbing. Plus I was constantly arguing with my younger sibling over what to watch. I spent the entire month locked up in my room reading books and listening to music. And after that month was over, I never had the same interest in TV again.
Nowadays we try other experiments like going vegan or using grey water to flush the toilet or increasing the number of days between showering. Often the main question behind these experiments is how I would deal with my life if I had no: electricity or tomatoes or water or whatever.
But there must be a downside to living on 46.76% of my income right? Why, yes!
1. I live in a crappy neighborhood. However, when I lived in Center City paying the same amount for a small one bedroom apartment in a gorgeous neighbood I also had problems…but never heard gun shots. Although…I did have to deal with bums sleeping outside my building and annoying drunks staggering all over the sidewalk.
I originally moved to my current neighborhood because I was going to take out loans to finish up my degree and I wanted to limit my living expenses as much as possible (husband was also in school and we were working PT). However, the apartment water pipes froze in the middle of winter and our heating system broke, and I had exams and my period and I was going mad with stress. So I moved into the current place after breaking my lease because we needed a place asap. I decided to stay on for a few months past our lease this year because we’re planning a cross country move and moving to a new place would increase costs only to move again across the country. So I decided to deal with living next to abused kids, pets, annoying banshees and practicing bands.
That’s the only downside. This post will have an abrupt ending because its getting too long.






if I die and husband decided not to kill himself from grief
Oh my god, Beany, you make me laugh!
Comment by arduous — April 18, 2008 @ 11:56 am
Have you considered the time spent on your extra saving habits like the grey water?
There are days I find the nickel and dimes savings are too time consuming or command energy or brain power I should use elsewhere. My effort into making bread didn’t yield great results, a flat sandwich loaf but it’s still edible and the experiment was fun. how do you strike a balance between fun/time consuming experiments?
Comment by sfordinarygirl — April 18, 2008 @ 3:22 pm
Good post, funny, thoughtful and had a tune I could dance to! We also try the experiments and try not to be tooooooo rigid. But extra time for gray water? I suppose so. We toss our dish water in a 5 gallon bucket, our shower heating water in a jug and our handwashing water in a basin and flush it all. I don’t feel it takes any extra time. Are you moving to a warmer climate?
Comment by equa yona — April 18, 2008 @ 7:12 pm
Thanks arduous and equa yona
And I’m moving to L.A. (at least that’s the plan), so yes it will be much warmer than here (PA).
SF: Actually we haven’t spent much time thinking about how much time we spend on our various projects. Its a matter of choice really. Like some people do coupon clipping, I think its a waste of time (and a pain in the neck). Or some people order take out, I just whip up something in the same amount of time.
As for our grey water project. It began when I started participating in the freeze yer buns challenge. We had justed brewed a batch of beer and were worried about our yeast dying due to the cold (we made an irish stout). We noticed that after showering our bathroom was often the warmest part of the house, so we stored our fermenter in the bathroom. Then we thought that it was such a shame to waste all that grey water after it cooled down, so we began storing it in buckets (that our neighbors were so kind to toss into our backyard) to flush the toilet. I then began thinking about how much drinkable water was being flushed down the toilet…and it bothered me.
Re: bread: to be honest, my first 5 or so attempts at making bread resulted in bricks. It was so disappointing. I mean I can make fantastic cakes…yet couldn’t make a simple loaf of bread. But eventually I began to get the hang of it.
I’ve been trying to make decent pita bread to no avail. But I can make pita chips (the dough is always too dry, if its too wet it smells too much like alcohol).
I also refuse to join a gym, so many of our experiments is a workout, like carrying a bucket of grey water from our washer to the bathroom.
Unlike equa yona, I don’t save the water from doing dishes. The water is too oily and I don’t want oil stains in the commode which would attract more grime. Its just one of those choices I made.
The other thing is despite all these experiments we have loads of free time. I took a 4 hour nap yesterday and mostly did nothing useful except making some food. We’re both slackers so I don’t find all these things to be work. I find it fun. I also actively spend time avoiding too many commitments as free time is extremely important to me.
Comment by Beany — April 19, 2008 @ 10:00 am
Re: How to strike a balance?
I don’t think I quite answered the main question regarding striking a balance. A few years back I made a list of things important to me and it basically was one thing: spending as much time with my husband as I can. So many of my choices are centered around that desire.
There is also the element of fun. This is something many of those rigid cost-benefit analysis or opportunity cost fans neglect to consider because their sole criteria for evaluating something is money. The one example I can think of is the idea Bill Gates (or some other wealthy dude) should not pick up a penny on the ground because the energy spent in picking up the penny could be better utilized someplace else. But what if he likes picking up pennies? To me, any minute I am not at work, I am not making money. If I get a penny savings out of something, its a penny I did not have before. I could make a lot of money doing taxes for the private sector, but I’d rather spend time playing with my compost worms or napping or working in an industry where I have a very flexible schedule and zero chance of working overtime.
I hope this makes sense…
Comment by Beany — April 19, 2008 @ 10:15 am
Funny post! I’ve become much more of a nickle and dime gal and love the consequences. My husband used to bitch about this- - but my standpoint is that all of those “drops” add up to a big bucket.
I think our society as bastardized frugalness as part of our consumer culture……breaking away from it has only made me happier.
LOVE your picture!
Comment by Going Crunchy — April 20, 2008 @ 3:31 pm
Crunchy: Thank you!
Comment by Beany — April 21, 2008 @ 5:23 am
You are truly my hero and model for frugality! I don’t feel so silly for making my own bread and botched recipes. You’re right - it is fun and it’s amusing to me so it’s not that bad after all.
Comment by sfordinarygirl — April 21, 2008 @ 3:58 pm
aww…I’m so touched that I am a hero to someone.
Comment by Beany — April 22, 2008 @ 5:39 am